Hmm, I would actually have liked to have chosen the First as lamest villain ever. It just talked and talked and talked. And the whole thing with Giles in S7 (is it Giles or is it the First? He hasn't touched anything/body in a billion episodes) sucked so much.

And it's not so much that I don't think Willow was redeemed. It's more that I was dissatisfied with how her arc was resolved with the whole magic addiction, etc. Since she failed to recognize what was really wrong, I'm not sure what she learned.